• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sir Pizza of Kentucky: A Local Favorite for Delicious, Unique Pizzas in Lexington

Sir Pizza of Kentucky, located at 463 W New Cir Rd, Lexington, offers a unique pizza experience that stands out in the crowd of national chains. Known for its friendly service and laid-back atmosphere, the restaurant delivers delicious, edge-to-edge topping pizzas cut into squares—a nostalgic touch for many. Customers appreciate the crispy crust and the small pepperoni pieces reminiscent of classic recipes. While feedback on salads has been less enthusiastic, the overall value and quality of the pizza make it a local favorite. With reasonable prices and a welcoming vibe, Sir Pizza invites you to savor a slice of Kentucky’s best.

Photos & Gallery

Sir Pizza of Kentucky: Reviews & Ratings

Bonita Dukes
Bonita Dukes

The woman working behind the counter had NO help & was responsible for everything. There was 1 driver but he was busy delivering. She remained calm, courteous & respectful. The pizza was not the best I've had from there but it was good nonetheless. My "salad" is where the trouble came in.They should be embarrassed that they sell this at all, but to charge almost $3 is downright shameful. The white iceberg was SOAKING wet. It's disgusting. Imagine what happens to a watery salad when dressing is added! Worse though, I ordered blue cheese and when I poured it on, it gushed out because it too had had water added A LOT! It had the consistency of water. Smh. I do wish they'd be a little more generous with the pizza sauce on their pizza & way less generous with the water in their salads. If they did, they'd get 5 stars plus. PS- again, the female who worked last pm at 11:30pm was GR8!! & SHE definitely deserves a raise.

David Mays
David Mays

I was staying in Lexington for an evening and decided I wanted pizza. I could've ordered something from one of the large national chains, but wanted to try something different. Sir Pizza was close and I was unfamiliar with them, so I placed a delivery order. The delivery did take a little while, but it was a Sunday evening and I don't feel the timeframe was that out of line. The pizza was really good and I loved that they used small pieces of pepperoni - definitely something I hadn't seen in years. The price was more than reasonable and I will be willing to try them again when I'm in the area.

Faith Hope
Faith Hope

Really laid back if you go inside. There was only 1 lady working the nite I was in there picking up my pizza. She got the pizza cooked fast and it was delicious . It's not a bad lil spot for real.

Steph orrill
Steph orrill

We had a great time at Sir Pizza with Ahmad! He is very friendly, lots of jokes, and the pizza was quick. We love the edge to edge toppings, crisp crust, and cut into squares. It reminds us of home (Dayton, OH).

Paula Wilcox
Paula Wilcox

Best pizza in town! Practically chopping up and toppings and putting them into the sauce covered in layers of cheese, genius and delicious! If you haven’t tried Sir Pizza you just don’t even know

Jonathan Richardson
Jonathan Richardson

Everyone needs Sir Pizza saved to their contacts that lives in Lexington they're the ones you can depend on when you need a late night snack or pizza on Christmas . I really liked my pizza today next time I'm asking for more sauce though I'm always extra saucy

Jimb
Jimb

Every time we come to Lexington I try to stop and get a large royal feast. Best pizza ever. Dining room may be a little run down but it makes you think just how long they have been there. I would rather eat in there as it is than go to a fancy place that is all perfect. Not many places like this still around.

Location

Welcome to the delightful world of Sir Pizza of Kentucky, located at 463 W New Cir Rd, Lexington, KY 40511. This charming little pizzeria offers a unique blend of flavors that make it stand out in a sea of national chains. While the address may guide you here, it's the fresh, mouthwateringly delicious pies that will keep you coming back for more.

At Sir Pizza, you'll find a cozy atmosphere that invites you to unwind. The laid-back vibe is further accentuated by the friendly staff. Many visitors, like Faith Hope, have noted the commendable service from the dedicated team, often highlighting the exceptional multi-tasking skills of the employees during busy hours. Despite being the only worker behind the counter, these individuals maintain a calm demeanor that adds to the welcoming experience.

When it comes to the food, Sir Pizza of Kentucky shines in a number of ways. Known for its edge-to-edge toppings, their pizzas are not only generously adorned but cut into square pieces, reminiscent of a homey, comforting style of dining. Steph Orrill emphasizes the crisp crust and layered toppings that create an inviting texture with each bite. The pepperoni is small and flavorful, a nostalgic nod that David Mays personally appreciated during his visit. This attention to detail enhances the overall dining experience.

However, it’s not all perfect. One customer expressed some disappointment regarding the salads, suggesting that improvements could be made in terms of quality and serving size. Yet, many agree that when it comes to pizza, Sir Pizza delivers, with flavors that can be described as both genius and delicious, as noted by Paula Wilcox. The base being a well-balanced blend of sauce and cheese, encourages a satisfying indulgence.

In conclusion, Sir Pizza of Kentucky offers a charming mix of great pizza, stellar service, and a welcoming environment that makes it a must-visit for anyone in Lexington. While there is room for refinement in some menu items, the core of their passion lies in crafting delightful pizzas that evoke a sense of nostalgia and are bound to grab the attention of local food lovers. If you haven’t yet tried Sir Pizza, it’s time to discover what you’re missing!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards